Wyoming vs Colorado: An Honest Side-by-Side on Taxes and Everything Else

By Cody Harvey · November 20, 2026

We help people move both ways across the state line. Some come up to Cheyenne. Some head down to Fort Collins, Loveland, Windsor or Greeley. We're licensed in both states, and we don't have a side.

Neither one is the right answer for everybody. Here's what each one actually costs you, and what each one gives you back, so you can pick the one that fits your life.

Income tax

Wyoming: no state income tax, personal or corporate.

Colorado: a flat 4.40% for 2025 and 2026. That's about $4,400 on every $100,000 of Colorado taxable income.

Here's the part that surprises people. Colorado taxes wages for work you do in Colorado, no matter which state you live in. So if your job is in Colorado, you pay Colorado income tax whether you live in Cheyenne or Fort Collins. Living in Colorado doesn't cost you a dime more in income tax.

Where it does make a difference: if you work from home, run your own business, are retired, or work for an employer in Wyoming, where you live decides which state taxes you.

Property tax

I ran the 2025 numbers on a $500,000 home inside Cheyenne city limits and a $500,000 home inside Fort Collins city limits.

Cheyenne. Wyoming assesses homes at 9.5% of market value. In 2025 the legislature took 25% off the value of a home, on the first $1 million. Starting in 2026, you have to live in the home at least 8 months a year to get it. Inside city limits, the 2025 levy is 70.54 mills.

$500,000, minus 25%, is $375,000. Times 9.5% is $35,625. Times 70.54 mills is about $2,513 a year.

Fort Collins. Colorado splits it in two: 6.25% for local government and 7.05% for schools in 2025. The City of Fort Collins tax area is 92.728 mills, and 54.09 of those go to Poudre School District.

  • Local: $500,000 × 6.25% = $31,250, times 38.638 mills = $1,207

  • Schools: $500,000 × 7.05% = $35,250, times 54.09 mills = $1,907

That's about $3,114 a year.

So on the same price, the difference is about $600 a year. That's real money, but it's not the reason to pick a town. A few more things worth knowing on each side:

  • Colorado: a lot of newer neighborhoods sit inside a metro district, which adds its own mills. Ask before you sign.

  • Wyoming: the 25% exemption only applies to the home you live in. A rental or a second home gets taxed on the full value.

Sales tax

Cheyenne: 6% total. Laramie County voters renewed the county's 1% on November 3, 2026, 19,212 to 11,109 in the unofficial results, so 6% stays.

Fort Collins: 8.30% total. That's 2.9% to the state, 1.05% to Larimer County and 4.35% to the city. In Colorado the rate changes by address, so check the town you're looking at.

Vehicle registration

Wyoming registration is based on your vehicle's value. The county fee is the factory price, times 3%, times a rate that drops every year: 60% in year one, down to 15% by year six. Then there's a state fee, $30 for a car. On a $40,000 car, that's $720 to the county in year one, plus the $30.

Colorado figures registration its own way. If you're moving either direction, pull your current registration bill and compare it with the new state before you plan your budget.

Beyond taxes: what each side gives you

Taxes are one line in the budget. How you want to live is the bigger question.

  • Weather: Cheyenne is wind country, so roofs and fences take a beating. The Front Range is hail country, so roof age matters a lot for insurance.

  • Getting around: Cheyenne to Fort Collins is about 45 minutes on I-25. In winter, Wyoming closes stretches of I-25 and I-80 for wind and snow, so a daily commute takes some planning either way.

  • Weekends: Northern Colorado puts Old Town, CSU, and the foothills close by. Cheyenne gives you open prairie, big sky, a downtown where people know your name, and Frontier Days every July.

  • What your money buys: prices aren't the same on both sides of the line, so the same budget gets you a different house. We'll pull the real numbers for the towns you're looking at.

The bottom line

There isn't a winner here. There's the side that fits your work, your budget, and how you want to spend a Saturday.

Want the whole process laid out? Grab our free Buyer Guide or our free Seller Guide. If you want to talk it through, text me at 307-317-6508. We're licensed in Wyoming and Colorado, so whichever side of the line you land on, we've got you.

I'm not a CPA, and this isn't tax advice. Before you make a move, sit down with a tax pro and run your own numbers.

Quick answers

Does Wyoming have a state income tax?
No. Wyoming has no personal or corporate state income tax.

If I live in Cheyenne and work in Fort Collins, do I pay Colorado income tax?
Yes. Colorado taxes wages for work done in Colorado, at 4.40% for 2025 and 2026, no matter which state you live in.

What's the sales tax in Cheyenne and Fort Collins?
Cheyenne is 6% total. Fort Collins is 8.30% total.

Cody Harvey

The Harvey Home Team | Compass
Call or text 307-317-6508

Sources

Facts checked November 20, 2026.

Previous
Previous

Moving to F.E. Warren: Buying a Home in Cheyenne With PCS Orders