By Cody Harvey · November 20, 2026
Almost every seller I meet has already looked up their home on Zillow. Some are thrilled. Some are crushed. Either way, in Cheyenne, that number deserves a second look, and here's why.
Wyoming keeps sale prices private
When a home sells in Wyoming, the buyer files a Statement of Consideration with the county. Wyoming law says that statement "is not a public record and shall be held confidential by the county clerk." That's W.S. 34-1-142(e).
So in Wyoming, the price your neighbor got for their house doesn't go into a public database. That's what people mean when they call Wyoming a non-disclosure state.
Why that matters for an online estimate
Zillow says its Zestimate pulls from public records, MLS data and details owners add themselves. For homes that aren't for sale, Zillow says it leans on tax assessments, prior sales and other public records.
Here's the catch in Cheyenne: the sale prices themselves aren't in those public records. The estimate has less real data to work with than it does in a state where every sale price is public.
How close is "close"?
Zillow publishes its own accuracy numbers. Nationwide, its median error is 1.80% for homes on the market and 7.21% for homes that aren't.
Take a $400,000 home that isn't listed. A 7.21% miss is about $28,840. And that's the median, meaning half of homes miss by more than that. Zillow also says plainly: "The Zestimate is not an appraisal."
That's not a knock on Zillow. It's a starting point, and Zillow says so. It just isn't the number to price your home on.
Where the real prices live
Agents report what homes actually sold for to the MLS. That's where real Cheyenne sale prices live, and it's what we use when we price a home.
What a real pricing consult looks at
When we sit down with you, we look at:
What actually sold nearby, at real closed prices from the MLS, not list prices.
What's on the market right now, because that's your competition.
What buyers in your price range are doing: how fast homes are going under contract and how close to list price.
Your home itself: updates, condition, lot, and the stuff a computer can't see, like the view out the kitchen window.
You'll walk away with a number you can trust and the reasons behind it.
Next step
Grab our free Seller Guide. It walks you through pricing, prep and the whole sale. When you want a real number for your home, text me at 307-317-6508.
Quick answers
Is Wyoming a non-disclosure state?
Yes. Wyoming law keeps the Statement of Consideration filed at a sale confidential, so sale prices aren't public records.
How accurate is Zillow's Zestimate?
Zillow reports a nationwide median error of 1.80% for homes on the market and 7.21% for homes that aren't.
What's the best way to find out what my Cheyenne home is worth?
A pricing consult built on real closed sales from the MLS, plus a look at your home itself.
Cody Harvey
The Harvey Home Team | Compass
Call or text 307-317-6508
Sources
Facts checked November 20, 2026.
W.S. 34-1-142(e), Statement of Consideration confidential: 2020 Enrolled Act: www.wyoleg.gov
Wyoming Dept. of Revenue rule 7-21: www.law.cornell.edu
Zillow Zestimate data sources, 1.80% / 7.21% median error, "not an appraisal": www.zillow.com